Last edited by Vuzshura
Wednesday, February 5, 2020 | History

2 edition of Option appraisal in the NHS found in the catalog.

Option appraisal in the NHS

R. L. Akehurst

Option appraisal in the NHS

a guide to better decision making

by R. L. Akehurst

  • 378 Want to read
  • 18 Currently reading

Published by Nuffield Provincial Hospitals Trust in [London] .
Written in English


Edition Notes

Statement[by] R. L. Akehurst and M. J. Buxton.
SeriesNuffield/York portfolios -- folio 8
ContributionsBuxton, M. J., Nuffield Provincial Hospitals Trust.
ID Numbers
Open LibraryOL13717310M

Why undertake an options appraisal? Appraisal of cases where benefits are the same for each alternative but costs differ is labelled cost-minimisation analysis CMA. Economic appraisal and economic evaluation are different names given to research studies that weigh the costs of an action against the benefits that it provides. Formally, the main decision rule for CBA is that an activity should be undertaken if the sum of the benefits that result is greater than the sum of the costs of undertaking it or, identically, if its net benefit is positive. However, as will be explained below, in health economics this term is often reserved for a particular technique related to the measurement of social efficiency, as defined in Section 1. This leads to a final recommendation about the preferred delivery model which can then be taken forward to the business case.

In the case of library services, councils are able to delegate their statutory functions. It is unambiguously worse than its alternatives, it is dominated and should be rejected. Wherever possible, the options appraisal should be quantitative — i. For example, suppose that there is an accepted decision rule that if the monetary benefits of a health intervention exceed its monetary cost then it should be provided to the population.

If only one activity with a positive net benefit can be undertaken because, for example, there are limited fundsthe activity with the highest net benefit should be chosen. Queen Margaret Hospital. For example, appraising the cost-effectiveness of a new drug should be reformulated as an appraisal of what is the most cost-effective way to deal with the problem that the new drug is licensed for. Who is going to do it?


Share this book
You might also like
Bible Christian Church in Upper Michigen

Bible Christian Church in Upper Michigen

Kay WalkingStick

Kay WalkingStick

GOES imager and sounder calibration, scaling, and image quality

GOES imager and sounder calibration, scaling, and image quality

From man to man; or, Perhaps only ...

From man to man; or, Perhaps only ...

Capital markets, foreign ownership and economic development

Capital markets, foreign ownership and economic development

Sweet Miss Honeywells Revenge

Sweet Miss Honeywells Revenge

The Russian tradition

The Russian tradition

DC-DC Power Conversion With Galvanic Isolation

DC-DC Power Conversion With Galvanic Isolation

Songs for today

Songs for today

Paediatric anaesthesia

Paediatric anaesthesia

Christmas holidays at Chestnut Hill

Christmas holidays at Chestnut Hill

Magic in art.

Magic in art.

Option appraisal in the NHS by R. L. Akehurst Download PDF Ebook

The New SCIM

In particular, it accepts that there may be benefits that are fundamentally different from each other and cannot be measured in the same units, which distinguishes it from Option appraisal in the NHS book analysis, discussed below, which requires a common unit of benefit.

Further detailed information and analysis contained in the original reports and surveys, but not included in the above mentioned summary document, is now presented to the Board to support its overall consideration of the General Hospitals and Maternity Services site option appraisal.

Some initial research should be carried out to understand the market context in which the delivery model will operate. Designated bodies wishing to use the form should also read the following guidance for organisations:.

Each of these activities is described in greater detail in the sections below. The other eight criteria were considered to be non site specific, except for "Reacting to Changes in Population and Disease", a part of which is site specific but is covered in the travel and access work.

Option Appraisal: A Practical Guide for Public Service Organisations (2017 Edition)

If this process is being undertaken with multiple stakeholders, it may be preferable to ask all stakeholders to individually consider a particular criterion or model, and then to discuss the results as a group before coming to a final consensus on the appropriate score.

One alternative will be preferred to another if it provides greater benefit at the same or lower cost, or costs less to provide the Option appraisal in the NHS book or greater benefit. Three different classification principles are: The kind of efficiency they analyse, technical, economic or allocative.

The Leadership behaviours assessment framework provides a summary of these behaviours and a useful framework for assessing positive and negative indicators. As outlined in section 1, you should use 3 main themes for investigation - Option appraisal in the NHS book, viability and feasibility.

The range of options identified are likely to sit along a spectrum of ownership and control which, at one end, will be entirely with the council for example an in-house serviceand at the other end, Option appraisal in the NHS book outside of it such as an outsourced service.

The form has been designed with the appraisal meeting in mind, in a logical manner that mirrors how the appraisal conversation may flow. Continuing improvements in quality. Why undertake an options appraisal? Impact ranking In essence a variation on the matrices exercises covered earlier.

The cost-effectiveness plane diagram can also be used to illustrate the meaning and use of the ceiling ratio, where it is often referred to as demonstrating cost-effectiveness acceptability: The dotted line Rc shows a given ceiling ratio. Each option must be scored against each criterion.

However, in principle it applies to all publicly funded activities. Wherever possible, the options appraisal should be quantitative — i. Hospital Inpatient flows have been examined along with "catchment" populations for North-East Fife.

Scoring mechanism - what do good and bad look like A definition to determine a high and low score for each criterion should be created.

Evidence shows this is balanced by the increases in Central Fife e. It may become obvious, for example, that one option has scored well against desirability but negatively against feasibility, with another option reversing these scores.

However, if there are economies of scale see section 1. These include: the anticipated procurement route proposed contract management arrangements back-office services such as finance, HR, payroll and legalin terms of whether the option will be required to purchase these from the council, or whether these can be procured from the open market asset transfer arrangements relating to property, equipment and other relevant assets including maintenance responsibilities staff transfer arrangements pensions and redundancy liability transfer arrangements This provides an opportunity to engage important stakeholders in the assessment process.

Ophthalmology, Urology. As can be seen from Chart 1, this has little effect on the catchment populations or in moving the centre of population westwards. The delivery model options are: remaining in house with re-engineering this should always be included as the status quo Local Authority Trading Company commonly referred to as a LATC Public Service Mutual commonly referred to as a PSM or mutual outsourcing to an existing social enterprise or charity; or to a for-profit provider joint venture potentially involving ownership and control by a range of stakeholders including but not limited to staff, the council, community agencies When identifying a long-list of options for delivery of library services, the following aspects should be taken into account: The strategic case for change The internal rationale for changing the method of service delivery.

This can be regarded as a balance sheet in which overall costs and benefits are weighed against each other. The ICER shows the cost of obtaining one additional unit of benefit for each alternative. If it lies in the north-west top left quadrant, such as point a, the costs of the intervention are higher than its alternative, and its benefits are lower.What is Turas?

Turas is NHS Education for Scotland's (NES) new single unified digital platform for health and social care professionals. From here you can access all your NES applications with a single secure sign on. Our aim is to provide you with the information and resources you need to support you throughout your career in the public sector.

Examples of Annual Objectives at other NHS Trusts King’s College Hospital NHS Trust: /14 Strategic Plan 1 • Goal 1: Quality improvement – safe, kind and effective care 1. Patient Safety – e.g. responding to The Francis Report and enhancing clinical and. NHS collaboration.

GP Tools has partnered with several NHS organisations which are some of the the most rigorous appraisal and revalidation team in the country to make sure that the portfolio and toolkit meets all the revalidation requirements as Read More.National Health Service Executive to amend current capital planning and implementation arrangements (EL(93)76).

Option appraisal in the NHS

In pdf, the NHS Policy Board and the NHS Executive are concerned to ensure that the systems operated in the NHS for the approval and delivery of major capital schemes are adequate to .What is Turas?

Turas is NHS Education for Scotland's (NES) new single unified digital platform for health and social download pdf professionals. From here you can access all your NES applications with a single secure sign on. Our aim is to provide you with the information and resources you need to support you throughout your career in the public sector.The principles set out in SCIM ebook applicable to the development of all investment schemes regardless of their size or complexity; and shall be applied by all NHSScotland Bodies (including Integration Joint Boards and similar requiring NHS investment support).